Sunday, December 11, 2011

Eat More ... Eurasian Collared Doves?

Eurasian collared dove, a beautiful scourge.
Editor's note: Apologies for the foray into the world of upland game bird hunting. I know this is a fishing blog, so if you're not into shotgunning, it won't hurt my feelings if you choose to skip this post.

The gravel crunched beneath my boots as I walked the lonely road down the hill toward the Snake River, my shotgun cradled across my left arm, and my tired old mutt wandering slowly by my side.

My feet were killing me. I had the makings of a couple of new blisters, and I'd managed to turn my ankle pretty good earlier that morning as we trudged across the steppe looking for huns. Then, as we walked an edge in search of the pheasants that taunted us by leaving behind very clear fork-shaped prints in the remnants of last week's snow, I tweaked it again. I was spent--four months spent largely sitting behind a desk had trickled the last of whatever was left of my stamina out of my bones. But I wasn't about to admit it. I masked the limp as best I could and powered through the pain in my toes (I learned later that I ripped one of my toenails completely off my toe).

"There are three things you need if you're serious about bird hunting," my good friend and an excellent wingshooter, Greg McReynolds, said to me as we walked slowly through the brush, half-heartedly hoping to move a flock of huns, and half expecting more of what we'd experienced most of the day, which wasn't much. "You need a dog, good shotgun shells and a good pair of boots. And I'm serious about the boots."

I looked down at my perfectly serviceable hiking boots that had taken me happily along trails all over the West. Then I realized my folly. Trails. Busting through brush and walking ditch rows behind eager dogs doesn't give the upland bird hunter the luxury of trails. Disturbed earth, rocks hidden under matted cheatgrass ... gopher holes that twist ankles ... they conspire against the tender-footed.

Boots. I'm in the market.

My dog, Hannah, has her heart in the right place. She's an instinctive bird dog, but not a trained shotgun dog. And she hunts about as much as I do, which means by the end of the day, she's as tired as I am. And as we walked slowly along the gravel road, relieved to be on level ground, she reluctantly marched by my side. Hours earlier, she happily pushed through cattails and ranged through sage searching for pheasants. Now, she walked on tender pads, tail a little droopy, but ears ever alert. Even this spent, she was attentive.

 In the distance, in the shade of the draw below us, we saw some birds moving.

"Collared doves," Greg said, almost dismissively. "We can shoot them. There's no limit."

Indeed, Eurasian collared doves, at least in Idaho, are considered a scourge, likely competing with native mourning doves for habitat, and perhaps even stressing more sensitive native game birds, like mountain quail and California quail. These beautiful birds first arrived on Western shores when they were imported as domestic pets in the Caribbean in the 1970s. By the early 80s, they were nesting in south Florida. A decade later, they were common all over the Southeast. A decade after that, they'd arrived in Idaho following a northwest expansion pattern that has seen them turn up as far north as Alaska.

Hearty birds that don't truly migrate--they simply expand their range, as they've done all across North America in a little over 30 years--Eurasian collared doves resemble mourning doves, but they're a quite a bit larger, and have a black "collar" on the backs of their necks. They might not be quite as big as a common banded pigeon, but they're not far off. Over the years, as I've come to see more and more of them all across Idaho, and at all times of the year, I've wondered about their habits, their habitat ... and their table fare.

As we got a bit closer, it became obvious that we'd stumbled upon this flock's roost, a copse of junipers lining a deep wash that tumbled down from the rim of the Snake River Plain to the water's edge. Dozens--maybe a hundred--of these big doves glided in and out of the junipers. Still well out of range, the itch to simply put a bird in my sights and pull the trigger on my father's old Remington 12-banger was almost more than I could stand. As we slowly marched a little closer, the birds got restless, but they didn't disperse. They were home for the night, and they weren't going to leave unless the approaching visitors turned out to be hostile.

And hostile we were.

I got close enough to where I felt comfortable taking a shot, and as soon as one of the doves left the roost and took flight, I raised my gun and fired. Feathers flew, and I was certain I had a bird down, so I moved to the next target, pumped the spent shell from the chamber and fired again. A clear miss, just a hair behind the target. A third shot was apparently errant, as well.

As I noted, I'm not a seasoned bird hunter, so a 33-percent success rate seemed pretty good to me. Hannah and I walked up on the juniper grove and we both combed the ground looking for my first collared dove. And we looked. And looked some more.

Greg brought his dog, Roxy, a seasoned bird dog, over to help us, but no luck. My suspicion is that I simply tagged the bird with just a taste of shot, and it sped off into the desert where, I'm guessing, it eventually became a nice meal for a fox or a coyote. It sure didn't end up in my freezer. A pang of guilt washed over me, but Greg wouldn't have it.

The $50 bird.
"Don't sweat it," he said. Then, in my language, he said: "It's like throwing a brookie on the bank when you're fishing a cutthroat stream."

The birds had moved over a ridge, but their odd flight pattern and the occasional appearance of a single or a double indicated that they really wanted to come back and roost in this thick copse of trees. Greg, taking pity on my sore feet, volunteered to wander around the next bluff and try to push the flock to me, where Hannah and I would wait. He and Roxy disappeared a few hundred yards away, and a few minutes later, I heard a single shot. Not long after that, a pair of collared doves appeared over the rimrock and made for the trees where Hannah and I sat in ambush. They flew into range, and I fired.

The trailing dove went down in a blast of feathers. Success.

Greg returned a few minutes later. Minutes after that, Roxy found my dove, dead in some thick brush.

We likely could have holed up in the trees and waited--I think the flock would have returned in time. But, with a day slowly slipping away, and the chance at a pheasant or two still in the cards, we humped it back to the car and fruitlessly pursued more prestigious prey until shooting hours expired.

The dove was our only take of the day, prompting me to calculate the investment I made into the hunting endeavor. I figured, between a tank of gas and the Arby's drive-thru I hit on the way home, I likely put $50 bucks into the two little breast medallions I gleaned from the gorgeous little immigrant.

So I figure the Eurasian collared dove population owes me one. I intend to collect.


  1. The question did that $50 bird taste? Divine = worth it
    Tough = still worth a good day outdoors

    Win-Win math

  2. Once immigrants from Turkey as well, these doves are a common species in this part of the world for quite a while now. They're mainly seen in our parks and gardens, but never in really great numbers. Actually I think they're quite charming, especially compared to other pigeons. But they sure don't look like they've much meat on 'm.


  3. Rebecca... I'll let you know. Ideally, I'll get a few more of them so we can actually enjoy an entire meal. I have some recipes, thanks to Hank Shaw's Hunter, Angler, Cook blog... I'll keep you posted.

  4. I dig the bird hunting post. We have the same Eurasian problem creeping up here in AZ...

  5. Chris, see now your talking my language now. Let's go find some more. I marinate them in Dakota Buckaroo marinating sauce. It's even made in Idaho. If we can't get enough for a meal we'll tap Ben for some more backstrap. Josh

  6. Josh... I'm in! I've been doing some research the last few night. Thinking about getting out between Christmas and New Years. Let's make it happen!

  7. Sweet. I took that week off of work.

  8. Chris,

    We need to go hunt these birds when all the hunting seasons are closed. I see them everyday in my neighborhood and have been tempted to hunt them with my son's bb- gun like I did as a child. I'm sure in February and March I'll be itching for an adventure. You in?


  9. Totally, Andy. A pellet gun would be ideal, although they were fun with a shotgun. I want to learn more about their habitat in semi-rural areas... In April and May... When the carp are in, they'd be fun to chase for a cast and blast.

  10. I've gone from learning about them just a few years ago (we'd notice occasional "big light mourning doves that don't leave on August 28th") to where for the last 2 weeks we've got *30* foraging and roosting in my back yard and trees (in southwest IF) every sunny midday. They're eating seeds and grain we set out for birds and squirrels, and as pretty as they might be, Collared Doves are voracious *pigs*.

    So eat up, Chris. Try stretching those two medallions out with a nice wild-rice pilaf or as a lunchtime snack. But hurry and report back. I'm curious what the h*** I'm getting myself into taste-wise before I fire a first shot -- we always mocked city-dwellers eating pigeons (squab) growing up, and now I'm a bit blocked on eating a winged rat.

    And since I'm not rural enough, I'm also open to folks brainstorming ways to do urban harvesting: a snare? trap? a pellet gun? Easiest of all would be stealing back my wrist-rocket from my daughter, and a bit of #4 shot.

    1. I've been harvesting them from my back yard with a Henry lever action .22 and aquila super colibri primer only rounds. They're quieter than my pellet gun. 20 yard head shots are no problem.

  11. I've been getting mine farther south... Found a roost where they all congregate on public land after feeding in the grain fields all day. Crops are full of grain and germinated winter wheat. If that's what they are eating, I am feeling pretty good about cooking them up.

  12. I'm such a bird-lover...that I have to cringe when I hear you talking about killing them. However, ... they are probably much healthier to eat then any chicken in the grocery store that is shot-up full with antibiotics and having to eat shit and also having had to endure the life of hell in some factory farm. Just say a prayer to thank it's spirit, ok.

  13. They've pretty much taken over my neighborhood. But that's part of the problem. In order to hunt them, I'd have to be hunting in town.